check_shell_coverage.sh has existed for a while and was never in
.pre-commit-config.yaml, so nothing ran it: a new shell library with no
suite beside it could land freely. Wiring it was unaffordable while the
gate measured a jail-run 100% bar (--all took over 600s). After 578c4a6c
dropped that, --all is 0.31s and the per-file mode this hook uses is
milliseconds, so it goes in.
Also fixes a bug 578c4a6c introduced: the failure path still interpolated
${COVERAGE_BAR}, which that commit deleted, so every rejection printed
"COVERAGE_BAR: unbound variable" and advised a 100% line-coverage bar
that no longer exists. The message now describes what is enforced.
Three libs blocked the wiring -- meta/scripts/lib/shell_coverage_{bar,
case_runner,jail_setup}.sh, the code that BUILDS the jail, and so the one
corner of the repo the jail cannot measure itself. They are pure
file-writers, so they get a suite that calls them against a temp $JAIL
and asserts on what was written: 48 assertions, nothing mounted, no
unshare, no kcov.
Several assertions check that an emitted file contains an UNEXPANDED
${BASH_SOURCE} or $1 -- the whole point of the quoted heredocs the jail
relies on. Written as single-quoted literals that is SC2016 on every
line, so the needles compose the dollar from an exported constant
instead. No suppressions were added.
check_shell_coverage.sh --all: 3 BLOCK -> 0 BLOCK
hook, repo-wide: 0.16s
new suite: 48 assertions, green
Proved the ratchet still bites: an untested lib dropped into
mtk_root/lib is refused with "needs: .../tests/run_all.sh". Probe removed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PJrqKERAo5QUeEHWS5Asgp
The gate was a presence check -- 'a run_all.sh exists beside this lib' --
which an empty suite that asserts nothing satisfies. It now measures.
100% is reachable with no suppressions and no production source changes:
run the suite inside a user+mount namespace and the sudo-writes, systemd
units and nftables rules execute for real against a throwaway /etc.
- meta/scripts/shell_coverage_jail.sh: the runner, promoted out of a
session scratchpad. Two fixes it needed on the way: bind targets mirror
the real directory tree (an empty bind makes writes fail with ENOENT,
which reads as unreachable code), and sudo gets a pass-through stub
because real sudo cannot setresuid inside a userns.
- It fingerprints git status before and after and fails the run if a
write escapes the jail. Verified with a deliberate escapee.
- dot_resolver_install.sh: 39/39 = 100.00%, 28 assertions. Picked by
scoring every allowlisted lib on root ops, system writes and
destructive calls -- it scored highest in the repo. Allowlist 106 -> 105.
- jscpd was already over its own threshold at 2.45% and would have
rejected every commit staging a .sh file. Excluding vendored .venv/
shell alone gives 1.67%; also excluding lib/tests/ gives 1.47%.
The gate is deliberately NOT wired into the hook chain yet.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01DbD4nco3EgL1UFoZKmKsLE
Three review findings, all before the hook is wired:
is_shell_lib excluded */lib/tests/* but not */tests/lib/*. Both are test
code; the second nesting made the gate demand tests/lib/tests/run_all.sh
for 10 helper files. It would have fired precisely while editing test
helpers to write the suites this ratchet asks for. Reseeded 125 -> 115.
--seed now refuses (exit 1) when a reseed would ADD an entry, instead of
a header comment asking nicely. It reads tracked files only, so an
unstaged probe seeds normally -- staging it produces the refusal with
the allowlist left byte-identical.
The parent commit's docs claimed an exempt file loses its exemption when
next modified. It does not: check_files exempts allowlisted paths
unconditionally, verified by staging an edit and getting exit 0. Fixed
the text, not the code -- making an edit trip the gate would block
routine work across 115 of 198 libraries, which is the repo-wide gate
this ratchet exists to avoid.
Also corrects the "a percentage is unreachable" rationale: commit
53e80462 reached 100% on an entry script with no suppressions. Presence
is still the right bar, because that took per-file mount analysis.
Measurement-only. No production file changed.
The gating question was whether the campaign's constraints are jointly
satisfiable: 100% line coverage over ALL .sh files with no suppressions.
Phase 1 measured effecting code at 0% under PATH shims, which implied
either forbidden suppressions or source seams in 17+46 files.
They are satisfiable. A user+mount namespace reaches 100% with zero
source changes: --map-root-user makes require_root fall through, and
bind-mounting each write target makes installer writes land in the jail.
setup_night_lockdown.sh went 81.58% (PATH shims) -> 86.84% (userns) ->
100.00% (38/38, all mounts).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01F3PzGc75gBcdxP3PkHXGcV
A shell library under a lib/ directory must now sit beside a
tests/run_all.sh. This is a presence gate, not a coverage percentage:
Phase 1 measured these libs' decision logic at ~90% under test but
their effecting code at 0%, because it sudo-writes, pkills and installs.
A numeric bar would only be reachable by shimming every external for
every installer, or by the suppressions this repo forbids.
Seeded at 125 exempt libraries out of 208 tracked; the other 83 already
have a suite. The allowlist shrinks only — a modified library loses its
exemption and must bring tests.
Verified standalone: blocks a new untested lib (exit 1), and does NOT
block covered libs, exempt libs, or unrelated entry scripts. That last
case is the point of a ratchet over the repo-wide gate.
The .pre-commit-config.yaml entry is deliberately NOT included — the
edit was denied as a sensitive file, so the gate is runnable but not
yet enforced.
