testsAndMisc/docs/superpowers/evidence/always-blocked-geofence-exempt-2026-08-10.json
Krzysztof kuhy Rudnicki b1de6f8d38 Take the geofence out of YouTube's reach, and pin infakt on
Leaving the house was an off switch. The AWAY branch returned early with
packagesToShow = every installed package, so walking 150m from home
restored YouTube -- which is the exact affordance device owner was
provisioned to remove.

always_blocked_packages is exempt from all four branches: AWAY hides
them, the allowlist loop cannot show them, and the workout release skips
them, because otherwise "go for a run" is the off switch instead. Chrome
is included as a second route to the same content; Firefox stays, and
carries the uBlock filters. Play is deliberately left geofenced so apps
can still be installed away from home -- and a hidden package cannot be
reinstalled from Play anyway.

infakt moves from the allowlist to SYSTEM_NEVER_DISABLE. Allowlisting
only held while it stayed in BOTH the day and night lists, and dropping
it from either would silently make it hideable; isAllowed() consults the
never-disable list before the curfew split, so it now holds under every
condition. It is device-paired to a bank over SMS, so losing it strands
the same re-authentication chain a hidden Messages app would.

The exporter now refuses an always-blocked package that is not also
blockable: the runner filters unopted system packages out of
installedPackages, so such an entry would never be hidden and nothing
would say so.

Verified: 128 Python tests at 100% branch coverage, 16 Kotlin tests, the
new ones canary-checked by breaking an assertion and confirming the
suite actually fails. On device, youtube/music/chrome/vending are
hidden=true, infakt hidden=false, uninstall still refused.

The AWAY path itself is unit-tested but NOT verified on hardware: with
no home_location.json every pass decides LOCATION_UNKNOWN, so the branch
is unreachable on this phone until coordinates can be provisioned.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_014DqEd1uUhyT52KjaNeLanC
2026-08-10 21:28:25 +02:00

53 lines
4.6 KiB
JSON

{
"intent": "Exempt YouTube, YouTube Music and Chrome from the geofence so they stay hidden everywhere, and make pl.infakt.infakt unhideable under every condition rather than merely allowlisted.",
"scope": [
"python_pkg/focus_policy/export.py",
"python_pkg/focus_policy/tests/test_export.py",
"focus_owner/android/app/src/main/kotlin/com/kuhy/focus_owner/FocusPolicy.kt",
"focus_owner/android/app/src/main/kotlin/com/kuhy/focus_owner/EnforcementDecision.kt",
"focus_owner/android/app/src/test/kotlin/com/kuhy/focus_owner/EnforcementDecisionTest.kt",
"phone_focus_mode/config.sh",
"focus_owner/assets/policy.json",
"Non-goal: network-level YouTube blocking, which the app cannot currently do at all"
],
"changes": [
"New always_blocked_packages field. The AWAY branch previously returned early with packagesToShow = everything, so leaving home restored YouTube -- the geofence was an off switch, which is what device owner exists to remove.",
"The exemption is applied in all four branches: AWAY hides them, the allowlist loop cannot show them, and the workout release skips them (otherwise 'go for a run' becomes the off switch).",
"com.android.vending deliberately NOT always-blocked: Play stays geofenced so apps can be installed away from home, and a hidden package cannot be reinstalled from Play anyway.",
"pl.infakt.infakt moved into SYSTEM_NEVER_DISABLE. Allowlisting depended on it staying in BOTH the day and night lists; isAllowed() checks the never-disable list first, before the curfew split, so it now holds unconditionally.",
"Exporter raises if an always-blocked package is not also blockable: the runner filters unopted system packages out of installedPackages, so such an entry would silently never be hidden."
],
"verification": [
{
"command": "pytest python_pkg/focus_policy/ --cov",
"result": "pass",
"evidence": "128 tests, 100% branch coverage on every focus_policy module (export/loader/model/blocklist/__main__)."
},
{
"command": "gradlew :app:testDebugUnitTest with a deliberately wrong assertion (canary)",
"result": "pass",
"evidence": "'16 tests completed, 1 failed' with AssertionError at the always-blocked case, proving the new tests actually execute rather than being skipped. Restored, then 16/16 pass. The pre-existing 'away from home hides nothing' test was updated rather than left passing, since it documented the hole being closed."
},
{
"command": "adb install -r over the device owner; run enforcement pass",
"result": "pass",
"evidence": "Success, Device Owner Type: 0 preserved. 'applied LOCATION_UNKNOWN: hid 0, restored 0' -- correctly a no-op, the packages were already hidden by the earlier pass."
},
{
"command": "dumpsys on the always-blocked set and on infakt",
"result": "pass",
"evidence": "youtube, youtube.music, chrome, vending all hidden=true. pl.infakt.infakt hidden=false. adb uninstall still returns DELETE_FAILED_DEVICE_POLICY_MANAGER."
}
],
"risks": [
"The AWAY exemption could NOT be verified on device: with no home_location.json every pass decides LOCATION_UNKNOWN, so the AWAY branch is unreachable on this phone today. It is covered by unit tests (canary-verified) but not by a real geofence transition. That verification has to wait for the in-app coordinate writer.",
"Because of the same missing coordinates, the user's 'other apps are fine' half is NOT yet delivered: everything is still hidden everywhere, not only the always-blocked set. The in-app 'set home to current location' action is now on the critical path for that.",
"isEnforcing is derived from packagesToHide.isNotEmpty(), so the always-blocked set keeps it true under AWAY and the uninstall block stays on. This is relied upon rather than stated as a separate flag; a future change making AWAY report not-enforcing would silently make `adb uninstall` reachable away from home. A test pins it.",
"The user's most important request -- blocking all YouTube hosts/URLs at the network level -- is NOT implemented. focus_owner does no network blocking of any kind. RethinkDNS is installed but at first-run state after the wipe (its 8 wildcard rules are gone) and is itself currently hidden by enforcement."
],
"rollback": [
"git revert; regenerate the asset; rebuild; install in place. The extra asset fields are ignored by an older build (optionalStringSet reads a missing key as empty).",
"To unblock one of the always-blocked apps without a revert: remove it from ALWAYS_BLOCKED_PACKAGES, regenerate, rebuild, install, run a pass."
]
}