testsAndMisc/.github/skills/code-review-and-quality/references/review-process.md
Krzysztof kuhy Rudnicki 346eb1f00b Bring every markdown file under the cap
Twelve prose violations to zero. Eight files split into per-topic
subdirectories with the original left as an index; both SKILL.md files
keep their frontmatter so discovery still works, with detail moved to
references/.

Deleted docs/cleanup-2026-05/ (7 files) and linux_configuration/docs/
VERIFICATION.md on the user's ruling: unreferenced records of finished
work whose rules are now enforced by the polling, shellcheck and shfmt
hooks. PACMAN_WRAPPER_SECURITY.md was split instead - unlike those, it
documents live guarantees.

Every split verified by a sorted diff against HEAD: zero content lines
lost, only the new headings and index links added.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_011w2Pj4Ek3ZNMQVYcFHgXDY
2026-08-16 19:25:59 +02:00

2.7 KiB

The review process and multi-model pattern

Review Process

Step 1: Understand the Context

Before looking at code, understand the intent:

- What is this change trying to accomplish?
- What spec or task does it implement?
- What is the expected behavior change?

Step 2: Review the Tests First

Tests reveal intent and coverage:

- Do tests exist for the change?
- Do they test behavior (not implementation details)?
- Are edge cases covered?
- Do tests have descriptive names?
- Would the tests catch a regression if the code changed?

Step 3: Review the Implementation

Walk through the code with the five axes in mind:

For each file changed:
1. Correctness: Does this code do what the test says it should?
2. Readability: Can I understand this without help?
3. Architecture: Does this fit the system?
4. Security: Any vulnerabilities?
5. Performance: Any bottlenecks?

Step 4: Categorize Findings

Label every comment with its severity so the author knows what's required vs optional:

Prefix Meaning Author Action
(no prefix) Required change Must address before merge
Critical: Blocks merge Security vulnerability, data loss, broken functionality
Nit: Minor, optional Author may ignore — formatting, style preferences
Optional: / Consider: Suggestion Worth considering but not required
FYI Informational only No action needed — context for future reference

This prevents authors from treating all feedback as mandatory and wasting time on optional suggestions.

Step 5: Verify the Verification

Check the author's verification story:

- What tests were run?
- Did the build pass?
- Was the change tested manually?
- Are there screenshots for UI changes?
- Is there a before/after comparison?

Multi-Model Review Pattern

Use different models for different review perspectives:

Model A writes the code
    │
    ▼
Model B reviews for correctness and architecture
    │
    ▼
Model A addresses the feedback
    │
    ▼
Human makes the final call

This catches issues that a single model might miss — different models have different blind spots.

Example prompt for a review agent:

Review this code change for correctness, security, and adherence to
our project conventions. The spec says [X]. The change should [Y].
Flag any issues as Critical, Important, or Suggestion.